AquaSonic Black Series vs AquaSonic Elite

Over three years, with heads at each maker's own pack price, the AquaSonic Black Series costs about $43 to the AquaSonic Elite's $72. Every other published figure for both is in the table, with the rows where they differ tinted.

AquaSonic Black Series electric toothbrush

AquaSonic

AquaSonic Black Series

No pressure sensor listed28-day battery · wireless base · travel case

~$40

Eight heads in the box is the Black Series' trick: at AquaSonic's four-month replacement interval, that covers more than two and a half years, so the three-year cost barely rises above the handle price.

Best for: The lowest three-year cost with heads already in the box

AquaSonic Elite electric toothbrush

AquaSonic

AquaSonic Elite

No pressure sensor listed28-day battery · wireless base · travel case

~$60

AquaSonic rates the Elite at 40,000 vibrations a minute, the same as the Black Series, and gives it five modes including Deep Clean, eight ProFlex heads and a hard-shell case.

Best for: A fifth mode and a hard-shell case over the Black Series, for $20 more

Specification comparison of the AquaSonic Black Series and the AquaSonic Elite
SpecificationAquaSonic Black SeriesAquaSonic Elite
Approx. price~$40~$60
3-year cost~$43 ($40 handle + 1 head at $3.12)~$72 ($60 handle + 4 heads at $3.12)
TypeSonicSonic
MotionSonic (vibrating head)Sonic (vibrating head)
Speed (maker's figure)40,000 vibrations per minute40,000 vibrations per minute
Pressure sensorNot listed by the makerNot listed by the maker
ADA SealNo listing foundNo listing found
Timer2-minute timer2-minute timer
Quadrant pacerYes, every 30 secondsYes, every 30 seconds
Modes4: Clean, Soft, Whiten, Massage5: Clean, Soft, Whiten, Massage, Deep Clean
ScreenNoneNone
Battery28-day battery (AquaSonic: "can last 4 full weeks (2 min/2x a day) on a full charge"; the same page also says "a full 30 days", and the lower figure is used)28-day battery (AquaSonic: "up to 4 weeks of use per charge")
Chargingwireless basewireless base
Travel caseYesYes
Heads in the box88
Head familyAquaSonic standardAquaSonic standard
Head compatibilityAquaSonic standard heads fit Black Series, Black Series Pro, Vibe Series, HDC Pro, Duo Series Pro and EliteAquaSonic standard heads fit Black Series, Black Series Pro, Vibe Series, HDC Pro, Duo Series Pro and Elite
Price per head$3.12 (AquaSonic Standard Replacement Brush Heads 8-pack, $24.95 on aquasonic.com)$3.12 (AquaSonic Standard Replacement Brush Heads 8-pack, $24.95 on aquasonic.com)
Replace heads every4 months (maker)3 months (maker)
Warranty1 year1 year

AquaSonic Black Series: what it gives up

  • AquaSonic lists a pressure sensor on none of its handles here, this one included
  • AquaSonic's four-month head interval is longer than the three months other makers give
  • ADA acceptance is AquaSonic's claim; the ADA listing does not name this model
  • One-year warranty, half the two years Oral-B, Philips and Oclean give

AquaSonic Elite: what it gives up

  • No pressure sensor listed; the Sonicare 5000 has one at the same $60
  • 40,000 vibrations a minute, under the 50,000 AquaSonic quotes for the $39 Precision
  • ADA acceptance is claimed by the maker but not confirmed on the ADA's list
  • One-year warranty, half what Oral-B, Philips and Oclean give

Full pages: AquaSonic Black Series · AquaSonic Elite